Contents
- 1 Find Out Who Provides Better Value - Energy Australia or AGL
- 2 Select your state to compare plans & prices
- 3 Energy Australia vs AGL Price Table
- 4 AGL vs Energy Australia Solar FiT
- 5 Energy Australia vs AGL Energy Features
- 6 Energy Australia vs AGL Payment Options
- 7 AGL vs Energy Australia Renewables
- 8 AGL vs Energy Australia Results
- 9 Should I Switch to Energy Australia or AGL?
- 10 Not Renewed Your Energy Contract In 12 Months Or More?
- 11 Interesting Reads
Find Out Who Provides Better Value - Energy Australia or AGL
Energy Australia and AGLare major players in the electricity retail market. Part of the well-known “Big 3”, these two energy providers have become a household name largely due to the fact that they serve millions of Australians across the country.
But name value alone doesn’t mean you’ll be getting great value. Each retailer has its pros and cons, which is why we’ve created this in-depth article to showcase everything from plan rates to renewable energy support. Plus, we cover some of the most common concerns and issues many Aussies face when switching retailers and offer a solution.
- My current electricity plan is too expensive.
- My benefit period has ended, and now I am paying more than before.
- I want a higher solar feed-in tariff rate. Can you help me?
- I want to switch energy providers. Can you facilitate the process for me?
Electricity Monster is your one-stop-shop for all your electricity needs. Tired of overpaying? We understand and feel your pain. Our energy experts believe you deserve a fair rate for a fair price which is why we work to find you the best deal we have available. If you’re keen on switching to a new retailer, call our energy experts at 1300 232 848 today.
Select your state to compare plans & prices
Energy Australia vs AGL Price Table
In our first match-up, we compare each retailer’s most competitive plan and showcase their current rates. Plans are subject to change, please visit the retailer’s official website to learn more.
Don’t pay more than you should for electricity. You may be able to secure a better deal. If you believe your power bill is too high, you’re not alone. There is a solution, and that’s Electricity Monster. Our 100% free service covers a variety of solutions including getting you connected to a new electricity provider, finding you a fair rate with one of our partnered retailers, and more. Don’t settle for high rates, phone us at 1300 232 848 now and let our energy experts help.
Energy Australia vs AGL NSW
In the table below, you’ll see rates offered by both electricity retailers in NSW. It is important to note that rates and plan information are subject to change. To learn more, please visit the retailer’s official website.
Electricity
Electricity plans are now compared to a government reference price. This makes it easier to compare energy plans across the market. The reference price comparison and annual estimate is calculated based on an average usage customer.
What's included in the discount and the price/year estimate
- GST (unless otherwise stated)
- Any advertised non-conditional discounts (e.g. guaranteed discount)
- Includes any one-off credits
What's not included
- Conditional discounts (e.g. pay on time discount)
- Green energy charges
- Any concessions or rebates which may apply to you
- Solar feed-in tariff credits that your solar system could generate
The reference price comparison will differ based on tariff type and location (distribution area). Your actual energy bill may be significantly different to these estimates if your usage differs from the average amounts used in this calculation.
| Retailer | Plan Name | % Below DMO* | Price/year (Est.) |
|---|---|---|---|
|
AGL NSW
|
AGL Value Saver |
22% | $1,086 |
|
Energy Australia NSW
|
Flexi Plan |
7% | $1,298 |
Gas
This gas estimate is calculated using an average gas amount based on ACIL Allen Energy benchmarks report 2017 in your distribution area.
What's included in the price/year estimate
- GST (unless otherwise stated)
- Any advertised conditional and non-conditional discounts
- Includes any one-off credits
What's not included in the price/year estimate
- Green energy charges
- Any concessions or rebates which may apply to you
The price/year estimate comparison will differ based on location (distribution area). Your actual energy bill may be significantly different to these estimates if your usage differs from the average amounts used in this calculation.
| Retailer | Plan Name | Discount | Price/year (Est.) |
|---|---|---|---|
|
AGL NSW
|
AGL Value Saver |
N/A | $730 |
|
Energy Australia NSW
|
Flexi Plan |
13% guaranteed discount on total bill and $25 credit for signing up online | $776 |
In the table below, you’ll see rates offered by both electricity retailers in VIC. It is important to note that rates and plan information are subject to change. To learn more, please visit the retailer’s official website.
Electricity
Electricity plans are now compared to a regulated price called the Victorian Default Offer (VDO). This makes it easier to compare energy plans across the market. The VDO comparison and annual estimate is calculated based on an average usage customer.
What's included in the price/year estimate
- GST (unless otherwise stated)
- Any advertised non-conditional discounts (e.g. guaranteed discount)
- Includes any one-off credits
What's not included in the price/year estimate
- Conditional discounts (e.g. pay on time discount)
- Green energy charges
- Any concessions or rebates which may apply to you
- Solar feed-in tariff credits that your solar system could generate
The VDO comparison will differ based on tariff type and location (distribution area). Your actual energy bill may be significantly different to these estimates if your usage differs from the average amounts used in this calculation.
| Retailer | Plan Name | % Below VDO* | Price/year (Est.) |
|---|---|---|---|
|
AGL VIC
|
AGL Value Saver |
14% | $1,124 |
|
Energy Australia VIC
|
Flexi Plan |
7% | $1,217 |
Gas
This gas estimate is calculated using an average gas amount based on ACIL Allen Energy benchmarks report 2017 in your distribution area.
What's included in the price/year estimate
- GST (unless otherwise stated)
- Any advertised conditional and non-conditional discounts
- Includes any one-off credits
What's not included in the price/year estimate
- Green energy charges
- Any concessions or rebates which may apply to you
The price/year estimate comparison will differ based on location (distribution area). Your actual energy bill may be significantly different to these estimates if your usage differs from the average amounts used in this calculation.
| Retailer | Plan Name | Discount | Price/year (Est.) |
|---|---|---|---|
|
AGL VIC
|
AGL Value Saver |
N/A | $990 |
|
Energy Australia VIC
|
Flexi Plan |
13% discount guaranteed on total bill and $25 credit for signing up online | $1,131 |
In the table below, you’ll see rates offered by both electricity retailers in QLD. It is important to note that rates and plan information are subject to change. To learn more, please visit the retailer’s official website.
Electricity
Electricity plans are now compared to a government reference price. This makes it easier to compare energy plans across the market. The reference price comparison and annual estimate is calculated based on an average usage customer.
What's included in the discount and the price/year estimate
- GST (unless otherwise stated)
- Any advertised non-conditional discounts (e.g. guaranteed discount)
- Includes any one-off credits
What's not included
- Conditional discounts (e.g. pay on time discount)
- Green energy charges
- Any concessions or rebates which may apply to you
- Solar feed-in tariff credits that your solar system could generate
The reference price comparison will differ based on tariff type and location (distribution area). Your actual energy bill may be significantly different to these estimates if your usage differs from the average amounts used in this calculation.
| Retailer | Plan Name | % Below DMO* | Price/year (Est.) |
|---|---|---|---|
|
AGL QLD
|
AGL Value Saver |
19% | $1,178 |
|
Energy Australia QLD
|
Flexi Plan |
2% | $1,430 |
Gas
This gas estimate is calculated using an average gas amount based on ACIL Allen Energy benchmarks report 2017 in your distribution area.
What's included in the price/year estimate
- GST (unless otherwise stated)
- Any advertised conditional and non-conditional discounts
- Includes any one-off credits
What's not included in the price/year estimate
- Green energy charges
- Any concessions or rebates which may apply to you
The price/year estimate comparison will differ based on location (distribution area). Your actual energy bill may be significantly different to these estimates if your usage differs from the average amounts used in this calculation.
| Retailer | Plan Name | Discount | Price/year (Est.) |
|---|---|---|---|
|
AGL QLD
|
AGL Value Saver |
N/A | $535 |
In the table below, you’ll see rates offered by both electricity retailers in SA. It is important to note that rates and plan information are subject to change. To learn more, please visit the retailer’s official website.
Electricity
Electricity plans are now compared to a government reference price. This makes it easier to compare energy plans across the market. The reference price comparison and annual estimate is calculated based on an average usage customer.
What's included in the discount and the price/year estimate
- GST (unless otherwise stated)
- Any advertised non-conditional discounts (e.g. guaranteed discount)
- Includes any one-off credits
What's not included
- Conditional discounts (e.g. pay on time discount)
- Green energy charges
- Any concessions or rebates which may apply to you
- Solar feed-in tariff credits that your solar system could generate
The reference price comparison will differ based on tariff type and location (distribution area). Your actual energy bill may be significantly different to these estimates if your usage differs from the average amounts used in this calculation.
| Retailer | Plan Name | % Below DMO* | Price/year (Est.) |
|---|---|---|---|
|
AGL SA
|
AGL Value Saver |
6% | $1,613 |
|
Energy Australia SA
|
Flexi Plan |
1% | $1,691 |
Gas
This gas estimate is calculated using an average gas amount based on ACIL Allen Energy benchmarks report 2017 in your distribution area.
What's included in the price/year estimate
- GST (unless otherwise stated)
- Any advertised conditional and non-conditional discounts
- Includes any one-off credits
What's not included in the price/year estimate
- Green energy charges
- Any concessions or rebates which may apply to you
The price/year estimate comparison will differ based on location (distribution area). Your actual energy bill may be significantly different to these estimates if your usage differs from the average amounts used in this calculation.
| Retailer | Plan Name | Discount | Price/year (Est.) |
|---|---|---|---|
|
AGL SA
|
AGL Value Saver |
N/A | $730 |
|
Energy Australia SA
|
Flexi Plan |
4% guaranteed discount on total bill and $25 credit for signing up online | $836 |
In the table below, you’ll see rates offered by both electricity retailers in the ACT. It is important to note that rates and plan information are subject to change. To learn more, please visit the retailer’s official website.
Electricity
Electricity plans are now compared to a government reference price. This makes it easier to compare energy plans across the market. The reference price comparison and annual estimate is calculated based on an average usage customer.
What's included in the discount and the price/year estimate
- GST (unless otherwise stated)
- Any advertised non-conditional discounts (e.g. guaranteed discount)
- Includes any one-off credits
What's not included
- Conditional discounts (e.g. pay on time discount)
- Green energy charges
- Any concessions or rebates which may apply to you
- Solar feed-in tariff credits that your solar system could generate
The reference price comparison will differ based on tariff type and location (distribution area). Your actual energy bill may be significantly different to these estimates if your usage differs from the average amounts used in this calculation.
| Retailer | Plan Name | % Below DMO* | Price/year (Est.) |
|---|---|---|---|
|
Energy Australia ACT
|
Flexi Plan |
3% | $2,018 |
Gas
This gas estimate is calculated using an average gas amount based on ACIL Allen Energy benchmarks report 2017 in your distribution area.
What's included in the price/year estimate
- GST (unless otherwise stated)
- Any advertised conditional and non-conditional discounts
- Includes any one-off credits
What's not included in the price/year estimate
- Green energy charges
- Any concessions or rebates which may apply to you
The price/year estimate comparison will differ based on location (distribution area). Your actual energy bill may be significantly different to these estimates if your usage differs from the average amounts used in this calculation.
| Retailer | Plan Name | Discount | Price/year (Est.) |
|---|---|---|---|
|
Energy Australia ACT
|
Flexi Plan |
5% gas guaranteed discount on total bills and $25 credit signing up online | $1,627 |
In the table below, you’ll see rates offered by both electricity retailers in WA. It is important to note that rates and plan information are subject to change. To learn more, please visit the retailer’s official website.
Gas
This gas estimate is calculated using an average gas amount based on ACIL Allen Energy benchmarks report 2017 in your distribution area.
What's included in the price/year estimate
- GST (unless otherwise stated)
- Any advertised conditional and non-conditional discounts
- Includes any one-off credits
What's not included in the price/year estimate
- Green energy charges
- Any concessions or rebates which may apply to you
The price/year estimate comparison will differ based on location (distribution area). Your actual energy bill may be significantly different to these estimates if your usage differs from the average amounts used in this calculation.
| Retailer | Plan Name | Discount | Price/year (Est.) |
|---|---|---|---|
|
AGL WA
|
AGL Set & Forget |
56% guaranteed discount | $532 |
AGL vs Energy Australia Solar FiT
Now, let’s dive into the solar feed-in tariffs offered by AGL and Energy Australia. The solar industry has seen substantial growth over the years. And with various financial incentives available to eligible households, it’s no wonder homeowners are considering switching to solar.
Maximum Feed-In Tariff (c/kWh)
| State |  |  |
|---|---|---|
| VIC | 10.00 | 6.70 |
| NSW | 10.00 | 6.70 |
| SA | 10.00 | 8.00 |
| QLD | 10.00 | 8.00 |
| ACT | 10.00 | n/a |
| WA | 0.00 | 0.00 |
Energy Australia vs AGL Energy Features
Rates and solar feed-in tariffs are key factors that homeowners consider when choosing a retailer, but there’s more to consider. This section covers the variety of features AGL and Energy Australia offer.
While financial incentives can be appealing, they should not be the sole factor that determines whether or not to sign with a retailer. Every feature should be considered. You may end up with a decent rate and a plan that suits your needs, but if you’re forced to pay on a fixed billing cycle for example, when you need more flexibility or have constant issues with their online portal, it can create issues that compound over time.
As you can see in the table provided, both Energy Australia and AGL offer customers similar features. The only feature Energy Australia does not currently offer is bill smoothing.
| Feature |  |  |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly Billling | Yes | Yes |
| Bill Smoothing | No | Yes |
| Online Account | Yes | Yes |
| Energy App | Yes | Yes |
| Rewards | Yes | Yes |
| Green Power Option | Yes | Yes |
| Carbon Neutral Option | Yes | Yes |
| Internet Bundles | Yes | Yes |
Energy Australia vs AGL Payment Options
When you’re paying your energy bill, you want some form of flexibility. The last thing you need is for an electricity provider to exclude your preferred method of payment. It can be frustrating and can even entice someone to switch to another retailer that offers more flexibility.
| Feature | | |
|---|---|---|
| Credit Card | Yes | Yes |
| Direct Debit | Yes | Yes |
| Phone | Yes | Yes |
| BPAY | Yes | Yes |
| Post Office | Yes | Yes |
| Centrepay | Yes | Yes |
| Cheque | Yes | Yes |
135,000
CUSTOMERS
“Extremely efficient and thorough help, absolutely fantastic job helping me get set up in my new home”
AGL vs Energy Australia Renewables
Renewable energy has become a hot topic in recent years. Many homeowners are considering an electricity retailer’s support for greener energy before they sign with them. This is why we want to showcase how ‘green’ both Energy Australia and AGL so you can make an informed decision.
AGL and Energy Australia recently participated in a study that measured their efforts towards sustainability and support for renewable energy. The data shown below was pulled from the 2020 Green Electricity Guide (GEG) by Greenpeace.
Both Energy Australia and AGL performed well in their support for new renewable energy, scoring an above-average 8 out of 10.
Conversely, both of these massive retailers dropped the ball in nearly every other category with multiple 0s across the board.
According to Greenpeace, AGL is Australia’s largest generator and retailer of electricity. They are also Australia’s largest polluter, accounting for 7% of Australia’s greenhouse gas emissions.
Energy Australia is also a major player in the electricity retail market. While Energy Australia does own renewable assets according to Greenpeace, they operate numerous gas power stations and large coal-burning power stations across the country. They are Australia’s second-biggest climate polluter.
The overall rating given by the Green Energy Guide has Energy Australia listed at a lowly 1.35 out of 10 and AGL at an even lower 1.2 out of 10.
| Feature | | |
|---|---|---|
| Providing clean, renewable energy | 0/10 | 0/10 |
| Ending coal use by 2030 | 0/10 | 0/10 |
| Halting fossil fuel expansion | 0/10 | 0/10 |
| Support for new renewable energy | 8/10 | 8/10 |
| Pollution & environmental harm | 0/10 | 0/10 |
| Transparency in marketing | 8/10 | 0/10 |
AGL vs Energy Australia Results
| Categories | Winner |
|---|---|
| Electricity Prices | |
| Gas Prices | |
| Solar FiT |  |
| Features |  |
| Payment Options | |
| Renewables | |
Should I Switch to Energy Australia or AGL?
Both Energy Australia and AGL have appealing offers, from electricity and gas plans to solar feed-in tariffs. But one thing’s for certain – it’s difficult to choose between the two. Both energy giants offer competitive rates, incentives, and other enticing features that make them both attractive. But before you consider switching to one of these retailers, we recommend phoning us at Electricity Monster first. There may be better deals currently on the market and our energy experts can help you find a fair rate with one of our partnered retailers.
If you’re worried about your rates being too high, need a new connection, or just want to explore your options, give us a call at 1300 232 844. At Electricity Monster, we are the solution for all your energy and gas needs. Our comprehensive service is 100% free to use, and our energy experts pride themselves on finding you the best deal we have available. If you’re ready to make the switch, trust Electricity Monster to get the job done.
Not Renewed Your Energy Contract In 12 Months Or More?
Lots of energy contacts only have benefit periods for 12 months. When your benefit period runs out, you may get moved onto a more expensive offer from your retailer. It is essential to check your plan to ensure it is still competitive. Call one of our free energy experts on 1300 232 848, who will review your energy plan and help you renew today.
Interesting Reads
Disclaimer
This publication reviews Energy Australia and AGL’s plans in VIC, NSW, QLD, SA, ACT, and WA published on their website as of 01/06/2022.
Important Points to note are:
- The plans displayed have been taken from the energy fact sheets published on the retailer's website. We do not guarantee that this information is correct or that it applies to every household in Australia.
- Comparisons have been made on the peak rates in single rate plans from retailers, plus their daily electricity supply charges.
- The Citipower network has been used to compare electricity plans, and the Australian Gas network has been used to compare gas plans in Victoria.
- The Ausgrid network has been used to compare electricity plans, and the Jemena gas network has been used to compare gas plans in NSW.
- The SA Power Networks network has been used to compare electricity plans, and the Australian Gas network has been used to compare gas plans in Victoria.
- The Energex network has been used to compare electricity plans, and the Australian Gas network has been used to compare gas plans in QLD.
- The Evoenergy network has been used to compare electricity plans, and the Jemena gas network has been used to compare gas plans in the ACT.
- The ACTO network has been used to compare gas plans in WA.
- The reference price/VDO/GAS comparison will differ based on tariff type and location (distribution area). Your actual energy bill may be significantly different to these estimates if your usage differs from the average amounts used in this calculation.
- The information in this blog cannot substitute for legal advice. No financial decisions should be made based on information from this blog.
- All dollar figures include GST.
- The plans displayed may be different than advertised.
- The plans offered on this page may not be available in our call center.
