AGL vs Energy Australia – Want to save over $270*?

* We do not compare all energy providers & have commercial arrangements with our partners.

Retailer Comparison | BY Ethan

When it comes to AGL vs Energy Australia, switching to AGL could save you $270* in some states.

If you like the sound of savings like this call us on 1300 232 848 or put your details in the form above.

Want more info? Let’s break it down.

AGL vs Energy Australia Residential Prices

We’re going to start off by looking at the rates because that’s probably what you’re here for. We’ll compare the best offered by each of these retailers in four major states – NSW, Queensland, Victoria and South Australia. In order to do this, we’ll be assuming the usage of a four-person household. For more information on this, please consult the footer of this article. 

How can these providers help your family?


Finally, we’ll take a look at South Australia. If you’re looking to cut a bit out of your power-bill, consider switching providers. If you go from the EnergyAus Secure Saver plan to the AGL Residential Essentials Saver, you could save over $270 a year. 

Energy AustraliaTotal Plan (Energy Australia)$ 2597
AGL EnergyResidential Essentials Saver (AGL Energy)$ 2322


First up is NSW and we’ll chalk up a win for Energy Australia. Based on our calculations,  AGL Residential Essentials Saver works out $70 cheaper than the EnergyAus No Frills plan. That’s a decent saving in a market as crowded as NSW. A good performance from Energy Australia considering No Frills is a discount-free plan.  

Energy AustraliaNo Frills (Energy Australia)$ 1963
AGL EnergyResidential Essentials Saver (AGL Energy)$ 1893


We’ll take a trip up north to Queensland for our next comparison, and AGL has managed to claw one back. Based on our calculations, we’ve got AGL Residential Essentials Plus beating Energy Aus No Frills by the massive margin of $100 a year. Not a huge saving to be had by switching from one to the other in Queensland.

Energy AustraliaNo Frills (Energy Australia)$ 1877
AGL EnergyResidential Essentials Saver (AGL Energy)$ 1774


In a competitive market like Victoria, it can be easy to think that your prices can’t get much better. However, switching to Energy Australia’s Total Plan could save you $20 a year. Squeezing every last penny has become vital in recent times, and a switch similar to this could really help. 

Energy AustraliaTotal Plan (Energy Australia)$ 1555
AGL EnergyResidential Essentials Saver (AGL Energy)$ 1573
Want to Save $250?*

Want to Save $250?*

Alinta Energy has rates that might beat both AGL and Energy Australia. Click here to learn more.

Learn More

AGL vs Energy Australia Business Prices

Up next, it’s time to see what’s in store for business customers. Both AGL and Energy Australia have some competitive business plans on the market, and we’ll be comparing the best of them. Just the way we did for residential customers, we’ll be assuming the usage of your business, in this case, it’s 40,000 kWh/year. We think this is a good number to work from but if you’d like more info, consult our disclaimer at the foot of this text. Let’s get started with a look at NSW.

Looking for a better deal for business?


As a business customer, it’s entirely possible for you to save thousands by switching energy providers. However, AGL and Energy Australia are pretty close in NSW. If you were to switch from AGL’s Business Essentials to the EnergyAus Total Plan, you’d save over $1300 a year.

AGLBusiness Essentials$12484
Energy AustraliaTotal Plan$11492


There are some bigger savings in store for Queenslanders looking to switch between these two providers. If you go from AGL’s Business Essentials to Energy Australia’s No Fuss, you might save nearly $400 a year. 

AGLBusiness Essentials$10482
Energy AustraliaNo Frills$10082


Switching from to EnergyAus No Frills plan to AGL’s Business Essentials plan might save you over $160 a year on your business electricity bill. When was the last time you cut some savings out of your business’s budget? 

AGLBusiness Essentials$10125
Energy AustraliaNo Frills$9961


South Australia is known for being quite expensive, but your business could shave $325 off your bill by switching to AGL’s Business Essentials from the EnergyAus Total Plan. 

AGLBusiness Essentials$16628
Energy AustraliaTotal Plan$16953
Alinta Energy Review

Alinta Energy Review

Want to learn more about other providers? Check out our expert review on Alinta Energy.

Start Saving

AGL vs Energy Australia – Awards & Customer Service
Sometimes you might want to consider what else an electricity provider can offer you. Knowing you’re going to get good customer service, if you’ve got an issue, can be a major weight off your mind. Here’s what both AGL and Energy Australia offer outside of the prices: 


We’ll start off by looking at what AGL has in store for their customers. Through their My Account function, AGL offers a variety of ways to handle your bill. These include: 

  • SMS pay
  • Direct debit
  • Bank transfer 
  • Bill smoothing

If you want, you can also get your bill delivered right to your email inbox and handle things that way. If you’re a bit on the old fashioned side, you can still pay the old way – through the mail or at the post office.

One of the coolest parts of AGL’s service is its vast rewards shop. Which grants you access to a bevvy of discounts on everything from dining to movies. 

Energy Australia

Energy Australia has been cleaning up the awards in recent times. These include big wins for:

  • Most Satisfied Customers (Small Businesses) – Canstar Blue, 2016
  • Most Satisfied Customers (Small Businesses) – Canstar Blue, 2017
  • Customer Satisfaction Award – Roy Morgan, June 2016
  • Another  Customer Satisfaction Award – Roy Morgan, July 2016
  • A third Customer Satisfaction Award – Roy Morgan, August 2016
  • #1 on the customer service index – Global Reviews, 2015
  • Another #1 on the customer service index – Global Reviews, 2016
  • A third #1 on the customer service index – Global Reviews, 2017
  • Their fourth #1 on the customer service index – Global Reviews, 2018

They’re also open to all sorts of alternative ways to pay your bill. You can settle your account through BPay or credit card, direct debit or Centrelink, or even though the mail. You can also give them a ring and set up a personalised payment plan.

AGL vs Energy Australia – The Results

Today we’ve compared two providers, but Electricity Monster can help you compare many more.

Just pick up the phone and make one call, a member of our team will guide you through the whole process.

It’s a 100% Free Service and could take as little as fifteen minutes.

If we’re able to find you a better deal from our providers, we can switch you over for free.

So give us a call on 1300 232 848 or pop your details in the form below. 

Compare Electricity & Gas Now

We can help compare your energy rates!

By using our service, you agree to our terms
Discover your new Electricity Rates!

So we can quote you via email, we need to search your meter type.



By using our service, you agree to our terms

* We do not compare all energy providers & plans in the market due to commercial arrangements.



This publication looks at how much a 4-person household pays a year, on average, on plans from Energy Australia and AGL in VIC, NSW, QLD and SA. The information in this document cannot substitute for legal advice. No financial decisions should be made based on information from this publication. Then again, individual usage, circumstances and brands could cause usage figures to vary.

Important points to note are:

  • In brief, we do not guarantee that the information applies to every household in Australia.
  • Significantly, all dollar figures are including GST unless explicitly mentioned.
  • The comparison is between a market offer that Energy Australia and AGL have in a state.
  • The plans chosen for comparison may not necessarily reflect the most competitive plans offered by Energy Australia or AGL.
  • Specifically, comparisons are on the peak rates in single rate plans from retailers, plus their daily electricity supply charges.
  • Electricity rates used are from the websites of electricity retailers. We have not verified their accuracy.
  • Chiefly, electricity benchmarks used for the average energy usage of households are from the AER website.
  • For Victoria, we have taken the Citipower distributor across all electricity retailers.
  • In NSW, the Ausgrid network is made use of.
  • As for QLD, we have chosen the Energex network.
  • For SA, SA Power Networks distributor is chosen.
  • *$150 of savings is based on our estimates of the top plans from Simply Energy and Energy Australia in certain states.

Written by Ethan


Ethan is an energy journalist with a passion for how the electricity industry affects regular people. His key areas of interest are the energy poverty crisis and inner workings of each state’s electricity situation.